But Then...

But Then...We Already Knew They Were Tough

An urban Red-tail Eyass beards the tough urban Catbirds


Urban House Sparrows are city scrappers. This one photographed by Eleanor Tauber

Isolde of the St. John's Cathedral nest, protects her youngsters from Kestrels and Crows at the same time,

Two pigeons soar in the Manhattan sky not in the least perturbed by a blimp, (Photo by Bill Walters),

And the Monarch of Central Park, Pale Male, the original tough urban raptor, scrutinizes his nest.


Cities Breed the Toughest Birds
Andrea Thompson

LiveScience Staff Writer

LiveScience.com

Sun Sep 30, 1:20 PM ET

Urban birds are regular tough guys compared to their country cousins. The avian urbanites adapt to changing environments and noisy, crowded habitats, a new study shows.

Birds that hang out on stoops and city streetlights have to deal with a set of challenges that feathered friends in more natural landscapes never encounter.

"The urban habitat is usually more severe than the habitats these birds historically occupied," said study team member John Wingfield of the University of Washington. "Urban habitats aren't easy, so the birds have to have developed coping mechanisms."

To find out which kinds of birds thrive in city environments, the researchers sent out questionnaires to ornithologists, biologists and birdwatchers all over the world that asked them to list the 10 most common native breeding birds found in their cities.

The responses named 217 urban bird species from 73 of the world's largest cities and 247 rural species. (Rural species were defined as those that did not breed in human-disturbed areas, such as towns and cities, and those for which their natural distribution overlapped with the area of at least one large city, implying they had lived there before humans moved in.)

Some well known city-dwellers, including starlings, parrots, crows, sparrows, pigeons and doves, showed up on the list, said study leader Frances Bonier, currently of Virginia Tech.

Some less common species found in cities included the black-tailed trainbearer, a tiny hummingbird in Quito, Ecuador; the green bee-eater found in Giza, Egypt; and a small bird called the broad-billed tody that lives in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic.

The research showed that worldwide, urban birds could endure a far broader range of environments than those which only lived in rural areas. Their elevation ranges were more than 1,600 feet broader and their distribution covered about 10 degrees more latitude, or 700 miles.
What gives city birds an edge over their rural relatives isn't known, but previous studies have shown that they have found ways to keep their stress levels down in the face of blaring horns and jackhammers and have changed their songs to make themselves heard over the din.

The new study's findings, detailed in the online edition of the journal Biology Letters, could be used to fine-tune conservation efforts by helping to identify the species that are least capable of dealing with an ever-changing and developing world. "

In the face of global climate change and human disturbances, such as increased urbanization and deforestation, we may be able to identify species that can cope with such changes," Wingfield said. "Then we may be able to identify the species that cannot cope with these changes, or might even go extinct in the face of increased disruption."

(Because even what seems to be the most obvious of hypotheses has to be tested to make sure what looks obvious is actually the answer. Do you remember the expensive study financed by the pet food industry in which they studied various diets to find the most healthful one for cats? It turned out to be....mice. Don't see Mouse Flavor Yummy Buffet in the canned cat food section? There are laws against rodent bits in canned food in the U.S.)

Donegal Browne