Trooper on Wednesday, looks down at the container of water before she plunges in.
While we wait for more news about Trooper in rehab (scroll down for the updates regarding her capture by Ranger Rob this morning, and becoming a patient, along with her already hospitalized sibling, under the wonderful rehab care of Cathy and Bobby Horvath), lets continue investigating the mystery as to who the bird in the water actually is.
Some reported this bird as Opera Star and some as Trooper, the sick fledgling. Disagreement on the identity of a sighted Red-tail are not all that rare even with watchers with many years of looking at Pale Male for instance.
Scroll down for Part I if you've not seen it yet to get up to speed.
It appeared to me from Jeff's photos that the fledgling in the bath was Trooper as he'd reported but some thought it not at all likely because of how energetic the bathing bird appeared.
Here is what Jeff had to say today about the episode.
Donegal,
Trooper Pool 5th Frame. Metadata time 1600.
Trooper Pool 7th Frame. Metadata time 1601.
Trooper Pool 9th Frame. Metadata time 1601.
Trooper Pool 13th Frame. Metadata time 1602.
Trooper Pool 14th Frame. Metadata time 1602.
Trooper Pool 15th Frame. Metadata time 1603.
Trooper Pool USED 17th Frame. Metadata time 1603.
Trooper Pool 24th Frame. Metadata time 1604.
(Have you been paying attention to the time changes?)
Note that the fluffy feathers abutting the leading edge of her wing are not wet.
Trooper Pool 25th Frame. Metadata time 1605.
Trooper was not bathing.
This is bathing. See the splashes of water flying through the air?
True the sparrow wallowing in the water is not a Red-tail but all birds wallow to a lesser or greater extent when bathing as far as I've ever seen. Red-tails have been known to even plop up and down in water. Whatever the case they make splashes and there are none in these photographs.
These photographs are of Trooper drinking and drinking and drinking. I posit that she drank, beak down, filled it with water, head up swallow water, rest a bit, look around, then do it again, for a solid five minutes. Unless of course Jeff somehow avoided all splashes in his photography which is unlikely.
Trooper of course was dehydrated from the poison and from not eating and obviously desperately thirsty but perhaps she was not aware what to do about it.
Eyasses get all their moisture from food, as likely fledglings do as well for awhile until they figure out drinking. Or in this case, even "remember" that drinking was one of the answers to her discomfort. Poisons do tend to also disrupt thinking, the brain is poisoned along with everything else in the body.
It appeared to me from Jeff's photos that the fledgling in the bath was Trooper as he'd reported but some thought it not at all likely because of how energetic the bathing bird appeared.
Here is what Jeff had to say today about the episode.
Donegal,
It's right to point out the seemingly impossible energy
displayed by the bathing fledge as being Trooper. I appreciate it being
questioned and at the time I looked at these on my MAC I was thinking
the same thoughts. At the very least I should have made a disclaimer
about possibly losing situational awareness when shocked to see a fledge
plop into its private pool. I didn't have a frame showing two
Red-tails…one on the wall and another in the pool. I would have shot one
for scene context since I'm shooting image data not NatGeo cover
images. I had no frame of a second Red-tail let alone a fledge in the
tree or on the wall at any time. Last September I had twelve year old
Abyssinian cat die of feline hemangiosarcoma. It's a rare a blood
cancer that there is a specific blood test required to find it. My cat
Romeo was looking like the papered show cat he was right until he had to
be euthanized. He had masked his disease for a year until it was too
late. From seeing how resilient Trooper proved to be, I thought she was
in a brief rally of spirit and masking her condition too. In light of
not seeing two fledges I elected to go with the proof I had that the
fledge in the pool was Trooper. Following are all th frames of the
fledge in the pool for possible better ID. They all have pushed
enlargement.
Trooper Pool 1st Frame. Metadata time 1600.
(Keep an eye on Trooper's activity and the time changes.)
Trooper Pool 2nd Frame. Metadata time 1600.
Trooper Pool 4th Frame. Metadata time 1600.
Trooper Pool 15th Frame. Metadata time 1603.
(Have you been paying attention to the time changes?)
Note that the fluffy feathers abutting the leading edge of her wing are not wet.
Trooper was not bathing.
True the sparrow wallowing in the water is not a Red-tail but all birds wallow to a lesser or greater extent when bathing as far as I've ever seen. Red-tails have been known to even plop up and down in water. Whatever the case they make splashes and there are none in these photographs.
These photographs are of Trooper drinking and drinking and drinking. I posit that she drank, beak down, filled it with water, head up swallow water, rest a bit, look around, then do it again, for a solid five minutes. Unless of course Jeff somehow avoided all splashes in his photography which is unlikely.
Trooper of course was dehydrated from the poison and from not eating and obviously desperately thirsty but perhaps she was not aware what to do about it.
Eyasses get all their moisture from food, as likely fledglings do as well for awhile until they figure out drinking. Or in this case, even "remember" that drinking was one of the answers to her discomfort. Poisons do tend to also disrupt thinking, the brain is poisoned along with everything else in the body.
Photos and italicized commentary by Jeff Johnson
Refreshed Red-tail. 1606 Metadata time.
I'm sure she did feel a lot better after her very long drink--- and refreshed and cooler from sitting in the water.
Now here are the rest of Jeff's photo picks of that day.
She decides to go aloft and sunbathe on the wall. 1606 Metadata time.
Sidling back and forth along the light fixtures of the roof she begins
some low voice begging. She must be pretty weak despite all the
energetic water play she's just done. 1618 Metadata time.
Time for a Red-tail squirt. 1630 Metadata time.
She flies back to her favored tree perch at the back of the MET.1651 Metadata time.
In this frame she looks very frail. 1738 Metadata time.
Indeed she does.
In case there was still any doubts that the hawk in the water was Trooper, see that her feathers near the bottom of her belly band are wet.
Back of the MET scene looking south. 1743 Metadata time.
She's decided to hide among the branching and foliage. 1836 Metadata time.
Her tree from looking east toward 5th Avenue. 1842 Metadata time.
Going back to the north side of the MET by the Temple of Dendur I check
for Opera Fledge where I saw him last night. It surprises me that
there's a silent Red-tail in the same area of the tree (upper left
corner). 1849 Metadata time.
Red-tail close. 1849 Metadata time.
It looks to be Pale Male when viewed from below. 1858 Metadata time.
That is absolutely Pale Male and he is wearing his very anxious face. He's just gone from three fledglings to one. I feel terrible for him. He shouldn't have to go through all this at his age.
It still looks to be Pale Male when you factor in CS6 auto color saturation. 1901 Metadata time.
Pale Male didn't seem to be going active so I went back toward the west
looking for Opera Star. I got back to where the ailing female was still
in her tree but now peeking around. Not begging that I could hear.
I want to comment here that since about 1500 there have been ongoing efforts by one hawk watcher and a Park entity to lure the sick fledge down from her perch so that she might be safely captured and treated for what ever is afflicting her. No frames were taken of these efforts to safeguard their noble undertaking. It's pretty sad that such a "blind" exercise must be pursued to promote the welfare of wildlife while providing a ruse of deniable guilt for the Park as an institution. 1907 Metadata time.
Let me clarify something. According to the laws of the land, the wild animals of the United States belong to all the people of the United States. That doesn't mean you can grab a hawk and take it home. Without authorization from the powers that be, that would be stealing from the rest of us. BUT, any citizen may lay hands on a wild animal who is in danger.
Say a fledgling is standing in the middle of Fifth Avenue, you may run out and grab it. Then once you are both out of the street, you take it to a safer place in Central Park, and let it go. That is perfectly legal.
Or if an animal is obviously ill, as this one is, or if it were injured, it is perfectly legal to get hold of it and then you have a certain number of hours to get it for medical care. That is within any citizens rights, and I personally would go further than that by saying for me at least, it is an obligation.
Therefore whoever, unless expressly forbidden personally to touch these animals due to prior behavior or just personally fearful due to possible displeasure of an employer, were within his or her rights to try to safely capture Trooper and get her to rehab. That is Federal law. And therefore drama shouldn't be necessary.
Off my soapbox now.
Going back to the Temple of Dendur I went to see what Pale Male was up
to. I found a Red-tail on the NW corner of the MET roof. It looked to
have dark coloration. 1914 Metadata time.
It pranced all along the edge of the roof . 1915 Metadata time.
In this frame it looks like it could be Pale Male if CS6 over-saturation is considered. 1915 Metadata time.
In this frame the Red-tail looks more like Opera Star.
(Can't be Opera Star as in the previous photo, the red unbarred tail of an adult is visible. Due to what looks like a possible window reflection attack in previous frame, if that is what it was, despite the color issue, I'd lean toward the hawk being Pale Male. Male Red-tails seem to be instinctively hair trigger wired in some way that makes them have a tendency to attack their reflection in windows when out of season they appear to know the image isn't another hawk. Glands. What can one do?)
Soon after this frame was taken the Red-tail swooped up into the air about three feet and disappeared south across the MET roof. I thought it might be a sign of Pale Male about to deliver a meal to the ailing fledge so I proceeded back to the west side of the museum. 1916 Metadata time.
Going to the back of the MET the female was looking very frail. 1937 Metadata time.
To my disappointment Pale Male never made an appearance and I had to
depart scene. I saw him perched on the NW corner of the MET as I left,
so I hope he delivered a meal after all. 1940 Metadata time.
Daughter Samanatha did not find either Pale Male or Zena today in her search of the territory today, the 26th. Neither did Jeff Johnson, though he watched Opera Star attempting to hunt for a good while.
Obviously just because Jeff and Samantha didn't see Pale Male or Zena on the 36h doesn't mean they weren't there of course.
Sometimes they just make themselves scarce.
Besides the fact they may have been looking far afield for the missing fledglings even though likely one or both saw them both leave with humans.
Now that I think of it, as far as I know, and I do find it very interesting that in all the rescues of fledglings, large and small, over the years by hawkwatchers in Central Park, not once has an adult Red-tail attacked the Good Samaritan.
By the way, if you did happen to see either Pale Male or Zena on the 26th or later, let me know, some folks are becoming concerned about them.
And for those who missed it the first time it was posted, click on the link to sign a petition directed to the DEC concerning rat poison and hawks--
http://www.change.org/petitions/new-york-state-department-of-environmental-conservation-stop-the-murder-of-our-red-tail-hawks-in-nyc
And please pass the link along to others who care!
Next up Jeff Johnson's time on Thursday with Opera Star. Well probably next up, unless there is more breaking news!
Donegal Browne
I'm sure she did feel a lot better after her very long drink--- and refreshed and cooler from sitting in the water.
Now here are the rest of Jeff's photo picks of that day.
Indeed she does.
In case there was still any doubts that the hawk in the water was Trooper, see that her feathers near the bottom of her belly band are wet.
That is absolutely Pale Male and he is wearing his very anxious face. He's just gone from three fledglings to one. I feel terrible for him. He shouldn't have to go through all this at his age.
I want to comment here that since about 1500 there have been ongoing efforts by one hawk watcher and a Park entity to lure the sick fledge down from her perch so that she might be safely captured and treated for what ever is afflicting her. No frames were taken of these efforts to safeguard their noble undertaking. It's pretty sad that such a "blind" exercise must be pursued to promote the welfare of wildlife while providing a ruse of deniable guilt for the Park as an institution. 1907 Metadata time.
Let me clarify something. According to the laws of the land, the wild animals of the United States belong to all the people of the United States. That doesn't mean you can grab a hawk and take it home. Without authorization from the powers that be, that would be stealing from the rest of us. BUT, any citizen may lay hands on a wild animal who is in danger.
Say a fledgling is standing in the middle of Fifth Avenue, you may run out and grab it. Then once you are both out of the street, you take it to a safer place in Central Park, and let it go. That is perfectly legal.
Or if an animal is obviously ill, as this one is, or if it were injured, it is perfectly legal to get hold of it and then you have a certain number of hours to get it for medical care. That is within any citizens rights, and I personally would go further than that by saying for me at least, it is an obligation.
Therefore whoever, unless expressly forbidden personally to touch these animals due to prior behavior or just personally fearful due to possible displeasure of an employer, were within his or her rights to try to safely capture Trooper and get her to rehab. That is Federal law. And therefore drama shouldn't be necessary.
Off my soapbox now.
(Can't be Opera Star as in the previous photo, the red unbarred tail of an adult is visible. Due to what looks like a possible window reflection attack in previous frame, if that is what it was, despite the color issue, I'd lean toward the hawk being Pale Male. Male Red-tails seem to be instinctively hair trigger wired in some way that makes them have a tendency to attack their reflection in windows when out of season they appear to know the image isn't another hawk. Glands. What can one do?)
Soon after this frame was taken the Red-tail swooped up into the air about three feet and disappeared south across the MET roof. I thought it might be a sign of Pale Male about to deliver a meal to the ailing fledge so I proceeded back to the west side of the museum. 1916 Metadata time.
Daughter Samanatha did not find either Pale Male or Zena today in her search of the territory today, the 26th. Neither did Jeff Johnson, though he watched Opera Star attempting to hunt for a good while.
Obviously just because Jeff and Samantha didn't see Pale Male or Zena on the 36h doesn't mean they weren't there of course.
Sometimes they just make themselves scarce.
Besides the fact they may have been looking far afield for the missing fledglings even though likely one or both saw them both leave with humans.
Now that I think of it, as far as I know, and I do find it very interesting that in all the rescues of fledglings, large and small, over the years by hawkwatchers in Central Park, not once has an adult Red-tail attacked the Good Samaritan.
By the way, if you did happen to see either Pale Male or Zena on the 26th or later, let me know, some folks are becoming concerned about them.
And for those who missed it the first time it was posted, click on the link to sign a petition directed to the DEC concerning rat poison and hawks--
http://www.change.org/petitions/new-york-state-department-of-environmental-conservation-stop-the-murder-of-our-red-tail-hawks-in-nyc
And please pass the link along to others who care!
Next up Jeff Johnson's time on Thursday with Opera Star. Well probably next up, unless there is more breaking news!
Good I hope.
Donegal Browne
4 comments:
Glad to see Pale Male is looking fine in Jeff's photos. I watched the short video of the sick fledgling drinking in the water pan on palemale.com, and it was, as you said, only drinking, no bathing going on.
Thanks for the back up Sally. :)
Hi Donegal,
I just read your great reporting on the blog about Trooper et al.
Had to say thank you so much for your caring and meticulous work.
I'm out in California, but feel that these are my RTs, too,
and it means quite a lot to be kept up-to-the-minute, and by
people who care deeply for these gorgeous beings.
So appreciative for people like you, the photographers, Cathy and Bobby,
the ranger........ all of you.
Sending the best thoughts for our hawks,
Jan Buckwald
Thanks you Jan. That means a lot to me. And yes, these hawks are the world's hawks. I'm so pleased that you too have taken them as your own. They stand in for creatures everywhere, who haven't the back up, and the access to communication that these do. :)
Post a Comment